Feature request : Somehow be able choose overlapping zones ?

[shodanx2]

Hi,

My main window looks like this

I like this layout, it has many possibilities as I can demonstrate here

explorer_xLb8FMb31x.mp4

However I would like to be able to have a larger snap zone of the full width, top and bottom

Like this

I don't know how the user would choose which of these overlapping zone however

Perhaps if there were a zone "drop zone" which is not the same the actual zone ?

Maybe something like this

Or maybe a gesture, or keyboard shortcut to switch layouts ?

I noticed that Alt+scrolling without drag, changes opacity, that's awesome, I like making "always on top, semi-opaque" transparent windows that I place above other windows !

I also noticed that Alt+scrolling with drag, cycles through the layered windows, that's clever.

I see that while Alt+dragging, right click toggles snap layout ... snapping, fantastic, that's just like I liked it in fancyzone

Lastly, I notice that Alt+dragging middle click does the same action as the right click.

I would like to suggest to change middle click to toggle the function the alt+leftdrag+scroll from window order flipping to snap layout flipping ?

(Also probably a post for a separate feature request, but can snap layout can be changed on a per monitor basis ? (although, I like that Alt+Snap does not shuffle my monitor layouts every time I disconnect/reconnect a monitor like fancyzone occasionnally does) )

Cheers !

----------unrelated comments-------------
Loving Alt-Snap snap zones lately BTW !
I've become acustomed to them and barely use FancyZone since I enabled hotclick
I am considering 3D printing a mouse with dual left/right, where a portion of the button does the alt-button.
In other words dedicated alt+left and alt+right buttons

[RamonUnch]

not yet read but just based on your title;

ZSnapMode=0
; Zone snapping strategy
; Set to 0 to snap to the zones pointed by the cursor (default).
; Set to 1 to snap to the zone which center is the nearest from the cursor
; There is always a the InterZone tolerance to snap to several zones.

[shodanx2]

Ok, giving this a try

First I create two new "full width" zones
And also I create two testing "drop zones"

Here is what is looks like (See zone list below)

Here is trying to snap this as is

WN8WuefzjG.mp4

With

ZSnapMode=1

Oops, the testing "drop zones" are causing issue

W4tTvKbMRw.mp4

I have now removed them

So, here we have the 8 original zones, plus two wide zones

Here is the result

ycMpvbw6yG.mp4

Here is the behaviour difference, Zsnap

So the following is no longer possible directly

It would be sweet to have custom drop zones that are independant from the actual snap location.
But ZSnapMode=1 is doing mostly what I want thanks !

So, just another suggestion for the backburner but this works for me right now !

Thanks !

Here is the zone list

Zone0=0,1055,3840,2111,
Zone1=0,1,3840,1055,
Zone2=2875,1,3840,1055,
Zone3=1920,0,2875,1055,
Zone4=964,0,1920,1055,
Zone5=0,1,964,1055,
Zone6=1256,1101,1627,1252,
Zone7=1255,868,1626,1019,
Zone8=2875,1055,3840,2110,
Zone9=1920,1055,2875,2110,
Zone10=964,1055,1920,2110,
Zone11=0,1055,964,2110,
Zone12=3406,-1105,3840,-50,
Zone13=3406,-2160,3840,-1105,
Zone14=0,-1105,533,-50,
Zone15=0,-2160,533,-1105,
Zone16=533,-2160,3406,-1105,
Zone17=533,-1105,3406,-50,
Zone18=-1718,1056,0,2111,
Zone19=-1718,1,0,1056,
Zone20=-3152,1,-1718,1056,
Zone21=-3152,1056,-1718,2111,
Zone22=-3840,1056,-3152,2111,
Zone23=-3840,1,-3152,1056,
Zone24=6991,1056,7680,2111,
Zone25=6991,1,7680,1056,
Zone26=5557,1056,6991,2111,
Zone27=5557,1,6991,1056,
Zone28=3840,1056,5557,2111,
Zone29=3840,1,5557,1056,

[RamonUnch]

However I would like to be able to have a larger snap zone of the full width, top and bottom

You can Hold Ctrl and extend the window to several zones.

You can change snap layout with a command lie parameter.

Also I do not understand your layout, you should only have 8 zones + 2 large zones + 2 thinny cute windows = 12 zones, not 30!

[shodanx2]

Thanks !

I just tried with CTRL but the "wide overlapping" zones override the CTRL

It is not a big deal, but I think it is the wide zones or the center zones but switching better probably can't be done on the fly.

Except maybe switching the Zsnapmode via the command line. But I don't have an obvious way to trigger this change in an ergonomic way. So in those cases I will just resize the window.

As for my zones, I cropped out the other monitors for brevity but forgot to remove them from the zone definition

Here is what the whole looks like

[Ichisich]

There are also the while moving actions.
Setting a button to maximize vertically will resize the window horizontally while snapping (shift invert).

I snap the window into the left upper zone and then press MB5 while still holding the window with shift+leftclick:

snap.mp4

[RamonUnch]

I am not sure what the issue is with your snap layout, but AltSnap will choose the union of all rectangles which center are within the InterZone tolerance. So in your case everything is logically expected.

When you aim between the two top-middle zones, then you are precisely pointing at the zone that covers the whole top-half screen (defined in your zones), and when you aim at the very middle of the screen, the closest zones are the two wide ones and the union of both of them is the whole screen.

[RamonUnch]

In your case you might be interested in using UseZones=5 and then only define non-overlapping zones and then the window will extend automaically when you drag the cursor without having to bother with Ctrl. the final rectangle will be the union of the rectangle your cursor starts in and the one you finish with (a bit like e selection rectangle).

[shodanx2]

Thanks for mentionning the InterZone setting

I bumped that to

InterZone=128

For my 4K screen and it has become much more please to snap accross sections.

It took some taking used to. But now I can even snap the middle regions with some fiddling and CTRL.

I didn't enables Zones=5 as most of the time I don't want to stretch accross all zones that I pass over while in snap mode

Rtzk0os9q2.mp4