You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Title: Enhance Anemoi Indexing Capabilities to Leverage Zarr's List Indexing
Description:
This issue proposes removing current limitations and inefficiencies in Anemoi Datasets' indexing by fully utilizing Zarr's list indexing capabilities. Currently, Anemoi imposes restrictions that prevent optimal use of list indices, leading to performance bottlenecks and code complexity.
Background:
Existing comments in the codebase suggest that these restrictions are based on the assumption that Zarr does not support list indexing. However, Zarr's zarr.array.Array.oindex[] method does provide support for list indices, as well as slices and None.
Current Limitations and Inefficiencies:
1. Limited Support for Multi-Dimensional List Indexing (Inflexibility 1):
Anemoi Datasets currently do not support indexing with two or more list indices on different dimensions. For example:
x=get_anemoi_dataset(...) # shape(dates, variable, ensemble, grid)date_index= [1, 3, 5]
ensemble_index= [0, 4, 2]
x[date_index, :, ensemble_index, :] # This is currently not possible
2. Issues with Mixed List and Slice Indexing (Inflexibility 2):
As highlighted in #162, there are existing issues with indexing using a single list index on one dimension and a slice on another.
3. Inefficient Handling of Non-Sequential List Indices (Inefficiency 1):
When a non-sequential list index of size n is used for a single dimension, the current implementation retrieves data by converting it into n separate slices of length 1. It then retrieves data for each slice individually and concatenates the results. This is evident in the code at [select.py#L54C1-L60C7](https://github.com/ecmwf/anemoi-datasets/blob/develop/src/anemoi/datasets/data/select.py#L54C1-L60C7). This approach is equal to or less efficient than using oindex[...] especially when dealing with large indices.
Proposed Solution:
Leverage Zarr's oindex() to support general list indexing in Anemoi datasets. This will remove the current restrictions on using multiple list indices and will allow for equal or more efficient retrieval of data for non-sequential list indices.
Benefits and Use Cases:
Improved Performance for Ensemble Dataloaders: Enables efficient list indexing on date and ensemble member dimensions, which is crucial for ensemble modeling.
Enhanced Dataloader Efficiency: (potentially) Amortizes the cost of reads for list indices within the same chunk, significantly improving performance for models processing large time chunks non-iteratively.
Title: Enhance Anemoi Indexing Capabilities to Leverage Zarr's List Indexing
Description:
This issue proposes removing current limitations and inefficiencies in Anemoi Datasets' indexing by fully utilizing Zarr's list indexing capabilities. Currently, Anemoi imposes restrictions that prevent optimal use of list indices, leading to performance bottlenecks and code complexity.
Background:
Existing comments in the codebase suggest that these restrictions are based on the assumption that Zarr does not support list indexing. However, Zarr's
zarr.array.Array.oindex[]
method does provide support for list indices, as well as slices andNone
.Current Limitations and Inefficiencies:
1. Limited Support for Multi-Dimensional List Indexing (Inflexibility 1):
Anemoi Datasets currently do not support indexing with two or more list indices on different dimensions. For example:
2. Issues with Mixed List and Slice Indexing (Inflexibility 2):
As highlighted in #162, there are existing issues with indexing using a single list index on one dimension and a slice on another.
3. Inefficient Handling of Non-Sequential List Indices (Inefficiency 1):
When a non-sequential list index of size
n
is used for a single dimension, the current implementation retrieves data by converting it inton
separate slices of length 1. It then retrieves data for each slice individually and concatenates the results. This is evident in the code at [select.py#L54C1-L60C7](https://github.com/ecmwf/anemoi-datasets/blob/develop/src/anemoi/datasets/data/select.py#L54C1-L60C7). This approach is equal to or less efficient than using oindex[...] especially when dealing with large indices.Proposed Solution:
Leverage Zarr's
oindex()
to support general list indexing in Anemoi datasets. This will remove the current restrictions on using multiple list indices and will allow for equal or more efficient retrieval of data for non-sequential list indices.Benefits and Use Cases:
anemoi/datasets/data/
directory.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: